Quick Answer:
If only the upstairs toilet bowl loses water when another fixture empties, the problem is most likely a venting or branch-drain issue serving that bathroom. Run a test that compares an upstairs and a downstairs toilet at the same time; if only the upstairs bowl changes, focus on the vent/branch for that floor rather than the main stack.
Why This Happens
Toilet bowls rely on a trap seal—water held in the trap—to block sewer gases and keep the bowl at its designed level. When a nearby drain discharges quickly (for example a washer, tub or shower), it can create negative pressure in a poorly vented branch. If the branch vent is blocked, disconnected, or sized/placed incorrectly, that negative pressure can pull water out of the bowl trap, lowering the visible water level.
If both an upstairs and a downstairs toilet drop together during the same test, the issue is more likely to involve the main stack or a larger vent. If only the upstairs fixture drops, the branch vent or the local drain run serving that bathroom is the likely cause.
If this began after work or a supply change, check related repairs — see Bowl loses water after remodel and Water level drops after turning water back on for troubleshooting tied to those situations.
Step-by-Step What to Do
1. Prepare for the test
- Have someone ready to run a large discharge: full washer drain cycle or a full bathtub/shower drain works well.
- Make sure upstairs and downstairs toilets are at normal rested levels before starting.
- Have a notepad to record what you see: which bowls drop, how quickly, and whether you hear gurgling.
2. Run the simultaneous comparison test
- Start the washer drain or empty a full tub while watching both the upstairs and downstairs toilet bowls at the same time.
- If only the upstairs bowl drops, that points to a branch vent or local drain problem. If both drop, the main vent/stack is more likely.
3. Inspect visible vent terminals and roof area (only if safe)
- Look at vent openings on the roof for obvious blockages like leaves, bird nests or heavy debris. Do not climb on a steep or icy roof—hire a pro if in doubt.
- From the attic, if accessible without removing insulation or disturbing electrical, trace the vent pipe serving the bathroom for disconnections or trapped debris.
4. Check for local drain or vent faults
- In the attic or ceiling chase look for crushed or disconnected vent sections, especially near where the branch connects to the main vent.
- Listen for gurgling during the test—gurgling at the upstairs fixture while the washing machine drains suggests air trying to move through the bowl trap instead of the vent stack.
5. Simple fixes and temporary measures
- After the discharge event, pour a bucket of water into the lowered bowl to restore the trap seal so sewer gas is kept out.
- Clear accessible debris from the vent opening if it’s safely reachable from a stable ladder. Avoid forcing tools down the pipe that could make things worse.
- If you suspect a hidden blockage, a licensed plumber can camera-inspect the vent and drain branch to locate the problem precisely.
What Not to Do
- Don’t assume an upstairs-only drop is “just normal low pressure.” That pattern usually indicates a branch vent or local drain problem, not general supply pressure.
- Don’t attempt unsafe inspections on steep roofs or uncomfortable attics; if you can’t inspect safely, a plumber is appropriate.
- Don’t pour strong chemicals down vents or drains to try to clear suspected blockages—those can damage plumbing and harm you.
When to Call a Professional
- If you cannot safely access the roof or attic where the vent runs.
- If the test shows only the upstairs fixture is affected and you can’t find an obvious, safe-to-fix vent blockage.
- If you smell sewer gas, see persistent gurgling, or multiple fixtures are behaving oddly—these are signs to call a licensed plumber who can camera the vent/drain and make secure repairs.
Safety Notes
- Do not climb on roofs without the proper ladder, footwear, and a helper. Slips on roofs cause serious injuries.
- Watch for attic hazards: exposed nails, insulation fibers, electrical wiring, and low clearances. Wear a dust mask and gloves if you enter an attic.
- If you detect strong sewer odors, ventilate the area and avoid prolonged exposure. Call a professional if you suspect a major sewer leak or backup.
Common Homeowner Questions
- Why did only the upstairs toilet lose water?
A vent or branch drain serving that bathroom is probably blocked, disconnected, or improperly vented, causing siphoning when a large nearby discharge occurs. - Is this an emergency?
Not always an immediate emergency, but restore the trap water and address it soon to avoid sewer gas and sanitation problems. - Can I fix it myself?
You can do the comparison test and clear obvious, safe roof-top debris, but if roof/attic access or camera inspection is needed, hire a plumber.
For more related articles, see the nan hub.